Nau mai, haere mai, welcome to EyeContact. You are invited to respond to reviews and contribute to discussion by registering to participate.

JH

Fletcher and Thatcher at Melanie Roger

AA
View Discussion
Graham Fletcher, Untitled (Lounge Room Tribalism), 2009-2010, oil on canvas, 1500 x 1200 mm Graham Fletcher paintings at Melanie Roger Part of the Tim Thatcher hang at Melanie Roger Graham Fletcher, Untitled (Lounge Room Tribalism), 2009-2010, oil on canvas, 1620 x 1300 mm Graham Fletcher, Untitled (Lounge Room Tribalism), 2009-2010, oil on canvas, 1620 x 1300 mm Graham Fletcher, Untitled (Lounge Room Tribalism), 2009-2010, oil on canvas, 1500 x 1200 mm Tim Thatcher, Home, 2010, oil on canvas, 505 x 660 mm Tim Thatcher, Wharenui, 2010, oil on canvas, 600 x 705 mm Tim Thatcher, New Linear Sculpture 11, 2010, oil on canvas, 300 x 230 mm Tim Thatcher, The Gardener, 2010, oil on canvas, 705 x 600 mm

Roger's coupling of these two artists is a clever, witty pairing: a comment on ownership, private display and storage.

Auckland

 

Tim Thatcher

Graham Fletcher

 

26 January - 19 February 2011

In this first show where Melanie Roger has taken over the Anna Bibby space with her own brand as dealer, we see works by the two painters Graham Fletcher and Tim Thatcher. Both use the traditional means of oil on canvas, but whereas Fletcher is tidy and pristine stylistically, Thatcher is rawer and consciously ‘rough’.

It is an interesting pairing with vivid contrasts. Fletcher’s canvases are a lot bigger than Thatcher’s, with tighter modelling and plasticity, and more elegantly composed, featuring interiors. Thatcher’s on the other hand are set outside with raggedy edges and mottled planes. Both come from their creators’ imaginations and have no ‘factual’ origins.

Thatcher’s images feature boxlike architectural forms rendered with a brusherly greasy daubed paint, often a dominant streaky greeny blue. They seem to be painted quickly and improvised on the spot. The best ones have a lively energy and vibrant organic texture.

Fletcher’s images differ in that there is a political subtext, a post-colonial undercurrent. The rooms depict fictitious collections of tribal (usually Polynesian) art but while the spaces are made up the specific ‘primitive’ items on display with the furnishings aren’t. They are carefully researched and accurately rendered, even though the accompanying wall-labels and titles lack this detailed information. Fletcher’s paintings are an imaginative hybrid of the photographs of Louise Lawler (that examine the domestic settings created for the collections of the wealthy) and the ironic ethnographic installations of Fred Wilson. Even though their political purpose is not stated, these images have a mood, a sense of resentful indignation that the rendered tribal carvings are now homeless, in an alien, inappropriate environment. The ancestral figures being used now as décor are slightly ominous, with a vague menace suggesting living presences.

Many of Thatcher’s paintings, instead of being about the display of art objects, look on the other hand to be preoccupied with their transport and storage - the figurative painting equivalent of a mimimalist like Noel Ivanoff. The depicted sheds or houses seem to be huge plywood crates where paintings are lined up and stored vertically in rows - and so Roger’s coupling of these two artists is a clever, witty pairing: a comment on ownership, private display and storage.

The show examines life for collected art (or functional objects) away from the institutions or locations they were originally made for. It has a sort of poignant melancholy, a wistful sadness, a yearning that interacts with Roger’s comparatively spacious gallery setting. An appealing incongruity that is inescapably political in its contradictions.

John Hurrell

 

Print | Facebook | Twitter | Email

 

Recent Posts by John Hurrell

JH
Olafur Eliasson, Life is lived along lines, 2009; Installation view: Olafur Eliasson: Your curious journey, Auckland Art Gallery Toi o Tāmaki, Auckland, 2024; Photo: David St George; Courtesy of the artist; neugerriemschneider, Berlin

Superb Eliasson

AUCKLAND ART GALLERY TOI O TAMAKI

Auckland

 

Olafur Eliasson
Your curious journey

 

7 December 2024 - 23 March 2025

JH
Jenny Holzer, STATEMENT - Truisms +, 2015, a four-sided vertical LED sign: with RGB diodes, stainless steel housing, robotic rotator and hoist, © 2015 Jenny Holzer, ARS. Photo: Collin LaFleche.

Holzer’s Cascading Truisms

AUCKLAND ART GALLERY TOI O TAMAKI

Auckland

 

Jenny Holzer
STATEMENT - Truisms +, 2015

Curated by Natasha Conland

 

27 March 2024 - 9 March 2025

JH
Gretchen Albrecht, Receptum, 1988, gouache and collage on paper, six panels, 2140 x 4700 mm (overall)

Collaging Albrecht

TE URU WAITAKERE CONTEMPORARY GALLERY

Titirangi

 

Gretchen Albrecht
Liquid States


3 November 2024 - 2 February 2025

JH
Ralph Paine, À la Leibnitz, eight framed drawings of watercolour and pencil. Each 230 x 310 mm.

Paine as Fan Boy

CHARLES NINOW

Auckland

 

Ralph Paine
Leaves From a Pillow Book

 

December 5 - December 21, 2024